Leaders in business, education and politics love to talk up how important Science, Technology, Engineering and Math (STEM) education is for America's future.
Innovations! Jobs! Progress! are all at stake, they often argue.
Just last week, President Obama hosted scores of mostly young people for an evening of stargazing and fun space talk at the second-ever White House Astronomy Night.
"Some of you might be on your way to Mars," the president told the crowd of future astronauts and scientists. "America can do anything! We just gotta keep on encouraging every new generation to explore and invent and create and discover. We got to keep encouraging some young kid in Brooklyn or a budding rocket scientist in Alabama or that young girl who's dreaming to become an astronaut."
Yet some in Congress either aren't hearing that message or disagree. Exhibit A: the giant, federal education law, No Child Left Behind, that Congress is currently struggling to update. The rewrite that the U.S. House recently passed eliminates the largest source of federal science education funding.
"The House bill would eliminate any specific focus on STEM education as a priority," says James Brown, the executive director of the STEM Education Coalition, a nonpartisan alliance of some 600 professional, business and education organizations that want to make STEM a national priority. "There's an existing program called the math and science partnership. The house bill would eliminate that. That would be a terrible blow to STEM education," Brown says.
The U.S. Senate's version is a different story. It expands the range of federal funds for science education, bolsters after-school STEM programs and creates a science education master teacher corps to reward excellent teachers, among other provisions.
But, with hard-line House Republicans in full revolt, it's possible the Senate's STEM provisions would disappear in the inevitable legislative horse-trading.
"People like to talk, but the actions don't measure up to words," says City College of New York physics professor Michael Lubell. He's also a fellow at the American Physical Society, which has long sounded the alarm on the need to bolster physics, science and math education. "STEM today is the child left behind. And it's being left behind at the juvenile level," Lubell says.
Lawmakers on both sides of the aisle talk about STEM as being critically important. "But the number of champions in Congress for STEM ed has actually gone down" in recent years, Brown says.
Lubell would like the federal government to prioritize STEM in the same way, say, the National Institutes of Health prioritizes finding ways to diagnose, prevent and cure human diseases. If not, he argues, the more than 20 percent of American children who live in poverty will continue to see the STEM education achievement gap widen.
"Certainly they don't have access to the same kinds of facilities, the same quality teaching, the same science curriculum that other children have. We're essentially writing off almost a third of our population," he says.
American companies regularly voice concern about the under-supply of qualified STEM workers. Growth in STEM jobs was three times as fast as growth in non-STEM jobs over the past decade, according to federal numbers. And STEM-related employment is projected to grow 17 percent between 2008 and 2018, far faster than projected overall employment growth.
A combination of budget cuts and policy decisions has left many local, state and federal bodies short on funds to robustly back science education. To help fill the gaps, a national patchwork of corporations, nonprofits, foundations and volunteers has stepped in to help.
Volunteer and corporate-backed STEM networks "can help schools bridge those gaps and make those connections," says Bruce Simon, associate director of the Gateways East Bay STEM Network, which helps schools bolster their science programs. "Where there is overlap, we can get that excess capacity to places that really need it," he says.
And in some districts, there are big gaps to fill. Just 45 percent of U.S. high school graduates in 2011 were ready for college work in math, and 30 percent were prepared in science, according to the advocacy group Change The Equation.
Far from Capitol Hill on a recent afternoon in Berkeley, Calif., a few dozen kids swarm in from the playground for some hands-on experiments on pressure.
The after-school STEM program at Rosa Parks Elementary School is taught by student volunteers from the nearby University of California, Berkeley.
"Can I have someone raise their hand and tell me what they see that's changed," asks Lynn Bajorek, a Cal senior and a volunteer with the group Berkeley Engineers And Mentors or BEAM. The cognitive neuroscience major has a midterm exam to study for, but she makes time to volunteer every week in local, project-based after-school STEM programs like this one.
In one of several elementary-friendly experiments, a hard-boiled egg is stuck in the opening of a glass milk bottle. Newspaper and matches are called in to ignite a controlled blaze inside. Soon, the newspaper burns off, and the kids yell with excitement as the egg is sucked into the bottle.
"Raise your hand if you know what a hypothesis is?" Bajorek asks, beginning a spirited conversation about what could have caused the egg to drop.
Rosa Parks Elementary already has a solid science program. But several of the other schools Bajorek and her team visit don't.
"Time for science — especially experimental, fun science demos — is completely cut out," Bajorek says. "So we want to kind of bring that back for kids. Or, for kids who don't want to just memorize definitions, it's much more engaging — a fun way to explore science."
"Shall we try it again? Who wants to see it again?" she asks the kids.
Their response is a loud, enthusiastic "Yes!"
STEVE INSKEEP, HOST:
President Obama talks often of the importance of Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math, or STEM, education. Here he is the other night, hosting scores of young people for Astronomy Night at the White House.
(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: Some of you might be on your way to Mars. America can do anything. We've just got to keep on encouraging every new generation to explore and invent and create and discover.
INSKEEP: But look at the giant federal education bill known as No Child Left Behind that Congress is now trying to update. There is concern that STEM education is getting nice PR, but not much support. Here's NPR's Eric Westervelt.
ERIC WESTERVELT, BYLINE: No, let's not go to Capitol Hill. Let's go to the classroom. A hard-boiled egg is stuck in the opening of a glass milk bottle. Newspaper and matches are called in. Call it a controlled blaze.
LYNN BAJOREK: So can I have someone raise their hand and tell me what they see that changed?
UNIDENTIFIED CHILD #1: It's going to explode.
UNIDENTIFIED CHILD #2: It's going to go down.
UNIDENTIFIED CHILD #3: The fire went out.
WESTERVELT: It's late afternoon at Rosa Parks Elementary School in Berkeley, Calif. A few dozen kids swarm in from the playground for some hands-on experiments about pressure. Soon after the newspaper burns off, the egg atop the glass jar is sucked inside.
UNIDENTIFIED CHILD #4: Why?
UNIDENTIFIED CHILD #5: The egg is going in.
WESTERVELT: Volunteer instructor Lynn Bajorek is a senior at UC Berkeley. The cognitive neuroscience major has a midterm to study for. But she and some other Cal undergrads make time to volunteer every week to promote project-based STEM education and local afterschool programs in the East Bay.
BAJOREK: Raise your hand if you know what a hypothesis is.
WESTERVELT: This elementary school, Rosa Parks, is lucky. They have a solid science program. But several of the elementary schools Bajorek and her team visit don't have any science curriculum at all.
BAJOREK: Time for science, especially experimental, fun science demos, is completely cut out. So we want to kind of bring that back for kids or for kids who don't just want to memorize definitions. It's much more engaging - a fun way to explore science.
WESTERVELT: Many local, state and federal bodies have come up short in their support of science education. So a national patchwork of groups, nonprofits, foundations, volunteers and companies are trying to fill the gaps. And there are big gaps. A case-in-point is the ongoing attempt, some eight years running, to rewrite the federal No Child Left Behind law. The version of the law the House recently passed eliminates the largest source of science ed. funding in the federal government. James Brown is director of the advocacy group the STEM Ed. Coalition.
JAMES BROWN: There's an existing program called the Math and Science Partnership Program. The House bill would eliminate that program. The House bill would eliminate any specific focus on STEM education as a priority.
WESTERVELT: Now, the Senate version is better on STEM. It expands the range of federal funds for science education, bolsters afterschool STEM programs and creates a science education master teacher corps. But with hard-line House Republicans in full revolt, chances aren't great that the Senate STEM provisions will survive the inevitable horse-trading. Physics professor Michael Lubell with the American Physical Society would like to see the federal government prioritize STEM the same way, say, the National Institutes of Health prioritize finding ways to diagnose, prevent and cure human disease. If not, Lubell argues, the nearly 25 percent of American children who live in poverty will continue to see the STEM education achievement gap widen.
MICHAEL LUBELL: Certainly they don't have the access to the same kinds of facilities, the same quality teaching that other children have. We're essentially writing off almost a third of our population.
WESTERVELT: If you look to Capitol Hill, Lubell says, STEM education today is at serious risk of being the child left behind. Eric Westervelt, NPR News, San Francisco. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.