Parents who are uneasy about their own math skills often worry about how best to teach the subject to their kids.
Well ... there's an app for that. Tons of them, in fact. And a study published today in the journal Science suggests that at least one of them works pretty well for elementary school children and math-anxious parents.
A team from the University of Chicago used a demographically diverse group of first-graders and their parents — nearly 600 in all — across a wide swath of Chicago. One group got to use an iPad app called Bedtime Math, built by a nonprofit with the same name. (The app is also available for Android, but we're told most used the iPad version) The no-frills app uses stories and sound effects to present kids with math problems that they can solve with their parents.
The control group was given a reading app with similar stories but no math problems to solve. The results at the end of the school year?
I reached out to University of Chicago psychology professor Sian L. Beilock, one of the paper's lead authors, to find out more.
I read to my child all the time. But I don't read bedtime math stories. After reading your study, maybe I should?
Our study suggests that doing Bedtime Math with your kids can help advance their math achievement over the school year, and this might be especially important for parents who are a little bit nervous about their own math ability.
That's me! How big an increase and what kind of improvement did you see when kids used this iPad app?
We compared kids who used the Bedtime Math app that involved reading stories and doing math problems with their parents to kids who did a very similar app that didn't have the math content. We showed that when kids frequently used the app with their parents, those who used the math app were three months ahead in terms of math achievement relative to kids who just did the reading app.
Your team found that the app worked even better for children whose parents tend to be a bit anxious or uncomfortable with math?
Many adults in the U.S. and around the world profess to be uncomfortable or anxious about math. Oftentimes dealing with your kid around math can be a nerve-wracking experience — whether it's homework or just talking about it. We found that doing this Bedtime Math app with kids was especially beneficial for those kids whose parents tended to be the most nervous about math. In essence, these kids grew significantly throughout the course of the year and looked like kids whose parents weren't anxious about math by school year's end.
And you saw improvement even in children who used the app with parents as little as once a week?
Yes, it was somewhat surprising to us that such little use would have such important benefits. One of the ideas is that we think that when parents get comfortable with talking with their kids about math — it doesn't have to be complex math problems, it could be anything from shapes to even counting — they likely engage in math talk even when they're not using the app. And we know that parents who talk more with their kids about math — whether you're counting out the number of cookies or counting the minutes to bedtime — those kids tend to achieve at higher rates in math.
Bottom line for you: A little bit of math can go a long way, at least in terms of this one study's findings?
That's exactly what we're showing.
There are a lot of apps out there. Why'd you choose this app in particular? What was special about it?
There is certainly a billion dollar education app industry out there. What we've realized in our initial work is that a lot of it isn't based on research. It's unclear what the benefits are. In fact, there has been some research that shows that apps with lots of bells and whistles can actually be detrimental to kids' learning because it distracts them. We base our investigations on learning science.
We've shown that, when parents interact with their kids and talk with them about math, that really impacts what kids learn. We were interested in this because it really is a no-frills app, an easy way for parents to interact with their kids, to talk with their kids about math. It's not an app that they use by themselves. And we thought that that potentially had promise in terms of what math knowledge kids gained.
I admit I'm kind of a math-anxious parent. But when doing stuff like woodworking, I try to incorporate a little geometry and basic measurement whenever I can. "Hey, let's measure this again! Twenty-four inches — how many feet is that?" It's a fun way to sneak a little bit of math in.
And to realize that math is part of everything we do, and math is not something scary or that one should be anxious about. And it's really healthy to try to incorporate that into daily life. And often, as you said, parents think about reading bedtime stories, but there is a place for thinking also about bedtime math.
Culturally and socially, it seems we don't think about math as integral a part of parenting as reading. And few adults would say, "I'm not so good at reading." But many people say, "I'm not so good at math." And somehow that's socially acceptable.
Yes, in my book, Choke, where I talk about stress and performance, I mention how you don't hear people walking around bragging that they're not good at reading. But very intelligent people brag about not being good at math. And it turns out that that anxiety and social acceptability has implications for our nation's success in math and science fields. And it's really important that we as parents and teachers and adults try to convey to our kids that math is something that's (a) enjoyable and (b) learned. You're not born a math person or not; it's something that's acquired. And every time we talk about it and we integrate it into our daily lives, children may see the importance of it and that math is not something to be fearful of.
Where do you think some of that math anxiety comes from?
Math anxiety comes likely from lots of different places. Previous work that my group has done shows that teachers who tend to be anxious about math affect their kids' perceptions of math and what they learn across the school year. We also know that when parents are anxious about math they can transfer that to their kids, especially when they're helping a lot with math homework. We tend to point to the schools to be the source for math knowledge. But kids spend lots of time outside of school and get lots of information from parents and from other adults. So being cognizant of how we talk about math and how we integrate it into our daily lives is important — both inside and outside the classroom.
Did you see any improvements in the parents' math ability by any chance [laughs]?
Ha, well, that's a really interesting question. We are just looking into those questions now. You can imagine that for parents who have a fear of math or less than optimal math training, it might take more than one school year to move the needle for them. But we are seeing improvements with their kids. And that's a first step. And we will be looking (in future studies) at how parents think about math, how they do in math, and most specifically their attitudes when interacting with their kids.
So there is hope for me?
There is hope for all of us! And, as you said, integrating these sorts of counting and math activities into daily routines is a great way to socialize both kids and their parents to the benefits of math.
KELLY MCEVERS, HOST:
I'm just not good at math. If you've ever said that and you're a parent, you might also worry about how you're going to help your child learn math. Well, there's an app for that, and a study published today in the journal Science suggests it actually works. Eric Westervelt, of the NPR Ed team, explains.
ERIC WESTERVELT, BYLINE: I read to my 5-year-old just about every day. A book about disgruntled crayons and one about a frog who lost his underwear are current favorites. Full disclosure though - I'm not a big math lover. So no, I don't read bedtime math tales or make up where the wild improper fractions roam stories. But University of Chicago psychology professor Sian Beilock says all of us should consider a little good night math.
SIAN BEILOCK: Our study suggests that doing Bedtime Math with your kids can help advance their math achievement over the school year, and that this might be especially important for parents who are a little bit nervous about their own math ability.
WESTERVELT: Beilock and her team followed a demographically diverse group of first-graders and their parents, nearly 600 in all, across Chicago for a year. One group got an iPad math story app to use regularly, called Bedtime Math, built by a nonprofit with the same name. The no-frills app uses stories with math problems and sound effects, like this...
(SOUNDBITE OF SOUND EFFECT)
WESTERVELT: And this...
(SOUNDBITE OF SOUND EFFECT)
WESTERVELT: Parents and kids solve the problems together. The control group was given a reading app with similar stories but no math problems to solve. The result at the end of the school year?
BEILOCK: Those who used the math app were three months ahead in terms of math achievement relative to those kids who just did the reading app.
WESTERVELT: And there's more. Beilock wrote the book about anxiety and performance, "Choke: What The Secrets Of The Brain Reveal About Getting It Right When You Have To." The study, published today in the journal Science, found that the Bedtime Math app worked even better for children whose parents tend to be anxious or uncomfortable about their own math ability.
BEILOCK: In essence, these kids looked like kids whose parents weren't anxious about math by school year's end.
WESTERVELT: The more families used the math story app the better they did. But in something of a surprise to Beilock's research team, even children who used the app with their parents as little as once a week saw significant math improvement.
BEILOCK: We think that when parents get comfortable with talking with their kids about math that they likely engage in math talk even when they're not using the app. And we know that parents who talk more to their kids about math, whether you're counting out how many cookies they're going to get or how many minutes till bedtime, those kids tend to achieve at higher rates in math.
WESTERVELT: So a little math can go a long way. Remember that next time you're measuring flour or cutting a two-by-four. Meantime, tonight at my house, I think I'll make up something about how four to the eighth power went walking in the woods. Eric Westervelt, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.