Linked To Haiti Cholera Outbreak, U.N. Considers Paying Millions In Compensation | KERA News

Linked To Haiti Cholera Outbreak, U.N. Considers Paying Millions In Compensation

Oct 25, 2016
Originally published on October 26, 2016 7:24 am

For years, the United Nations has refused to publicly acknowledge that its troops were the source of a massive cholera outbreak in Haiti in the wake of the 2010 earthquake.

But now the U.N. is accepting "moral responsibility" for the outbreak that has sickened nearly 800,000 people and killed more than 9,000 others.

The U.N. is currently hashing out a plan that could spend nearly half a billion dollars to address cholera in Haiti. The plan includes compensating Haitians who were "most affected" by the outbreak. This may include direct payments to Haitians who got sick or lost a family member to the disease.

"We see this as a very important sign of solidarity with those directly affected by cholera," U.N. Deputy Secretary-General Jan Eliasson said in a telephone interview with NPR.

The 2010 outbreak, which is ongoing, has been linked to sewage that leaked from a U.N. base. It's the first recorded cholera outbreak in Haiti in 100 years.

Deputy Secretary-General Eliasson says the assistance and compensation package is still not finalized nor is it funded. Half the money is to fight ongoing transmission of the disease, he says.

"The first track involves intensifying our efforts to treat and eliminate cholera as well as to improve long-term access to clean water and sanitation," he says.

The second track is the compensation: providing roughly $200 million in "material assistance" to cholera victims in Haiti. The money may go directly to victims or it may go to communities that were hard hit. Eliasson says these details haven't been finalized. This proposal is a sharp reversal for the U.N., which continues to fend off legal challenges from people who contracted cholera or lost family members to the disease.

Eliasson says the U.N. has not changed its legal position that it is immune from claims stemming from the outbreak.

"We have immunity," he says. "For us who have hundreds of operations around the world in very poor and uncertain circumstances, we run serious risks of getting into situations where this [liability] could lead to huge amounts of damages or claims. So therefore we've developed this model that we hoped will in practice be the same as models some of the lawyers are suggesting."

But Philip Alston, a law professor at New York University, disagrees. Alston, who serves as a U.N. Special Rapporteur on extreme poverty and human rights, says this new plan to compensate Haitians without accepting full responsibility sets a terrible precedent.

"As the U.N. begins to operate in more and more countries around the world and as there are greater risk of these kinds of negligence claims, the U.N.'s position will be 'We are not accountable. We refuse accountability,' " Alston says.

But it's not even clear if this plan will ever be carried out.

The proposal still needs to be presented to the U.N. General Assembly. Eliasson says some member states are uncomfortable with paying direct compensation to victims.

"Some of the member states do not consider this normal development work and would rather see the funding come from some other sources," Eliasson says. "So this is a work in progress. We expect to finalize this in a week or two."

Other countries may simply be unwilling to contribute millions of dollars to repair a blunder by the world body.

Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

KELLY MCEVERS, HOST:

The United Nations is considering spending hundreds of millions of dollars to help Haiti deal with cholera. U.N. peacekeepers were the ones who brought the disease to Haiti six years ago. The U.N. plan is not yet finalized or funded, but on the table are direct payments to Haitians, who the U.N. says were most affected by the outbreak. NPR's Jason Beaubien reports.

JASON BEAUBIEN, BYLINE: For years, the U.N. had refused to accept responsibility for a massive cholera outbreak in Haiti in the wake of the 2010 earthquake. Among all of the challenges facing Haiti, one problem the country did not have on its list of woes up to that point was cholera. The outbreak, which has been linked to sewage from a U.N. base, made hundreds of thousands of Haitians sick, and so far has killed more than 9,000. Now the U.N. admits it played a role in the original outbreak and wants to do something to fix it. Deputy Secretary-General Jan Eliasson, in a briefing to the U.N. member states, has laid out a two-prong $400 million plan to tackle cholera in Haiti.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

JAN ELIASSON: The first track involves intensifying our efforts to treat and eliminate cholera as well as to improve longer-term access to clean water and sanitation.

BEAUBIEN: The second track, he said, is to provide roughly $200 million in cash and material assistance to cholera victims in Haiti. This is a sharp reversal for the global body, which continues to fend off legal challenges from people who got sick or lost family members to the disease. A spokesman for the U.N. secretary general today in New York said the U.N.'s legal position on the outbreak hasn't changed. The U.N.'s refusal to formally state that it introduced cholera into Haiti, he said, shouldn't stop the organization from trying to deal with the problem. But Philip Alston, a U.N. special rapporteur on extreme poverty and human rights who's been advising the U.N. on this issue, said today that this new plan to compensate Haitians without accepting full responsibility sets a terrible precedent.

PHILIP ALSTON: As the U.N. begins to operate in more and more countries around the world, as there are greater risks of these sorts of negligence claims, the U.N.'s position will be we are not accountable. We refuse accountability.

BEAUBIEN: And it's not even clear if this plan will ever actually be carried out. The big question right now is whether the U.N.'s member states will be willing to contribute hundreds of millions of dollars to repair what's come to be seen in Haiti and increasingly elsewhere as a deadly blunder by the world body. Jason Beaubien, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.