U.S., Canada Announce New Safety Standards For Oil Trains | KERA News

U.S., Canada Announce New Safety Standards For Oil Trains

May 1, 2015
Originally published on May 1, 2015 8:18 pm

Transportation officials in the U.S. and Canada are imposing tougher safety standards on trains hauling crude oil.

U.S. Transportation Secretary Anthony Foxx and Canada's Transport Minister Lisa Raitt announced Friday that shippers must use stronger tank cars to haul oil across North America by October 1. The new rules will also mandate the use of a controversial braking system on trains carrying crude.

And these rules were a long time in the making. Safety advocates have been calling for sturdier tank cars for decades, especially in the 22 months since a runaway oil train exploded in downtown Lac-Mégantic, Quebec, killing 47 people.

There have been several other fiery derailments of oil trains, too. Though none were deadly, the sharp increase in the amount of oil that is hauled by trains is a big concern.

"Since 2008, we've seen a staggering, staggering, 4,000 percent increase in the transport of crude by rail," Foxx says, adding that 99.9 percent of those oil shipments reach their destination safely.

"The accidents involving crude and ethanol that have occurred, though, have shown us that 99.9 percent isn't enough," he says. "We have to strive for perfection."

The two governments are now requiring new tank cars to be built with thicker steel shells, protective shields, thermal lining and stronger valves to help prevent the cars from rupturing when they derail. Older tank cars will have to be retrofitted within a couple of years, or they will be pulled off the tracks.

The trains cars also will be required to travel at slower speeds, and will need to be equipped with an advanced electronic braking system.

"I know that the safety measures that we have outlined today will not be easy — and quite frankly, they will not be cheap," Raitt says. "We can never undo the damage that took place in Lac-Mégantic or in any other railway accident. But we can — and we must — learn from those events and improve our system."

But oil producers and railroad officials already are balking at some of the regulations.

Edward Hamberger, president and CEO of the Association of American Railroads, says regulators are imposing the advanced braking system based on what he says is a flawed study.

"How does that stack up against the president's call for good common-sense regulations, when you're basing a regulation on a study that the author himself says 'should be taken with a grain of salt? ' " he says.

Some question whether manufacturers can build enough new rail cars and retrofit older ones fast enough to meet the governments' deadlines. And David Friedman of American Fuel and Petrochemical Manufacturers says the regulations will do little to prevent derailments.

"These tank cars don't breech unless they've gone off the tracks, so our message continues to be that we've got to keep the cars on the tracks," he says.

More than 40 oil trains roll through the city of Aurora, Ill., each week. Mayor Tom Weisner says the new rules are full of holes, and do little to protect those who live near the rails.

"I don't think our federal regulators did the job that they needed to do here," he says. "I think they, uh ... wimped out, as it were."

Copyright 2015 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

MELISSA BLOCK, HOST:

The U.S. and Canada are opposing tougher safety standards on trains hauling crude oil. U.S. Transportation Secretary Anthony Foxx and Canada's Transport Minister Lisa Raitt announced today that shippers must use stronger tank cars to haul oil across North America. The regulations also mandate the use of a controversial braking system on trains carrying crude, as NPR's David Schaper.

DAVID SCHAPER, BYLINE: The new rules for tank cars were a longtime in the making. Safety advocates have been calling for sturdier tank cars for decades. And those calls have increased in the 22 months since a runaway oil train exploded in downtown Lac-Megantic, Quebec, killing 47 people. There have been several other fiery derailments of oil trains, too. Though none were deadly, the sharp increase in the amount of oil that is being hauled by trains is a big concern.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

ANTHONY FOXX: Since 2008, we've seen a staggering, staggering 4,000-percent increase in the transport of crude by rail.

SCHAPER: Transportation Secretary Anthony Foxx says 99.9 percent of those oil shipments reach their destination safely.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

FOXX: The accidents involving crude and ethanol that have occurred, though, have shown us that 99.9 percent isn't enough. We have to strive for perfection.

SCHAPER: So the two governments are now requiring new tank cars be built with thicker steel shells, protective shields, thermal lining and stronger valves to help prevent the cars from rupturing when they derail. Older tank cars will have to be retrofitted within a couple of years or pulled off the tracks. Oil trains will have to travel at slower speeds, and they'll need to be equipped with an advanced electronic braking system.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

LISA RAITT: I know that the safety measures that we have outlined today will not be easy and, quite frankly, they will not be cheap.

SCHAPER: Canada Minister of Transport Lisa Raitt.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

RAITT: We can never undo the damage that took place in Lac-Megantic or in any other railway accident, but we can and we must learn from those events and improve our system.

SCHAPER: But already the oil producers and the railroads are balking at some of the regulations. Edward Hamberger is president and CEO of the Association of American Railroads. He accuses regulators of imposing the advanced braking system based on what he says is a flawed study.

EDWARD HAMBERGER: How does that stack up against the president's call for good, common-sense regulations when you're basing a regulation on a study that the author himself says should be taken with a grain of salt?

SCHAPER: Some question whether manufacturers can build enough new railcars and retrofit the older ones fast enough to meet the government's deadlines. And Tom Friedman of the American Fuel and Petrochemical Manufacturer says the new regulations do little to prevent derailments.

TOM FRIEDMAN: These tank cars don't breach unless they've gone off the tracks. So our message continues to be that we've got to keep the cars on the tracks.

SCHAPER: More than 40 oil trains roll through the city of Aurora, Ill., each week. Mayor Tom Weisner says the new rules are full of holes that do little to protect those who live near the rails.

TOM WEISNER: I don't think our federal regulators did the job that they needed to do here. I think they wimped out, as it were.

SCHAPER: The new regulations on trains transporting oil and other flammable liquids will go into effect October 1. David Schaper, NPR News, Chicago. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.