Majority Of Americans See Trump's First Year As A Failure | KERA News

Majority Of Americans See Trump's First Year As A Failure

Jan 18, 2018
Originally published on January 18, 2018 2:07 pm

As President Trump approaches the one-year anniversary of his inauguration, a majority of Americans think that his first year in office has been a failure and that he has divided the nation.

NPR/PBS NewsHour/Marist poll data released Thursday finds that Americans deemed Trump's first year a failure, 53 percent to 40 percent. And by an almost 2-to-1 ratio (61 percent to 32 percent), Americans said they believe Trump has divided the country since his election.

Americans give Trump relatively positive marks on his handling of ISIS and the state of the economy — no small things. But they disapprove of his handling of just about every other issue or think things have gotten worse — from their views of the tax plan to the state of race relations and women's rights to immigration, health care, the deficit and foreign policy, including his approach to North Korea. Seven in 10 Americans are now concerned about the possibility of war breaking out with the rogue nuclear nation.

"The first-year grades for Trump are not good," said Lee Miringoff, director of the Marist Institute for Public Opinion. "He remains with his base intact and not much else. People remain doubtful in the institutions of our government, doubtful in how he's communicating things and how he's handling things. It's not a pretty picture for the president after the first year."

A majority of Americans continue to disapprove of the job Trump is doing overall (53 percent), think the country is headed in the wrong direction (57 percent), overwhelmingly believe his policies are directed toward helping the wealthy (60 percent) as opposed to the middle class (25 percent), and see his use of Twitter as a risky way to communicate (78 percent) that isn't sending the right message.

Trump still enjoys loyal support from his core and unwavering base — but not many others. He has slipped with independents, for example, a group he won in 2016. None of that bodes well for Republicans in this year's midterms.

Not meeting expectations

Nearly half of Americans (46 percent) said Trump's presidency has fallen below their expectations. A third said he has met their expectations, while just 15 percent said he has exceeded them.

A third of Americans said Trump's first year was a "major failure." Just 15 percent described it as a "major success."

Notably, half of independents called Trump's first year in office a failure, including a 30 percent plurality who said it was a "major failure."

Forty-four percent of independents said Trump had fallen below their expectations as president in his first year, while 36 percent said he had met them. Just 16 percent said he had exceeded.

Unsurprisingly, there is a sharp partisan divide — 87 percent of Democrats called Trump's first year a failure and 71 percent said he had fallen below their expectations as president.

On the other hand, 87 percent of Republicans called his first year a success, with 37 percent saying it was a major success. Among core Trump supporters, 91 percent also said it was successful, with 40 percent saying it was a major success.

Continued steady and historically low approval

Trump's approval ratings also remain low — with just 37 percent approving of the job he is doing as president overall while 39 percent strongly disapprove.

Those numbers are virtually unchanged from the past several months, as Trump's base remains in his corner — 85 percent of Republicans approve of the job he is doing, along with 90 percent of Trump supporters.

But again problems with independents show up for Trump — just 38 percent of them approve of his job performance.

Better or worse?

Americans overall are pessimistic about the general direction of the country under Trump. Forty-two percent said the country has changed for the worse under this president, just 36 percent said it has been changed for the better, and 21 percent said they've seen no real change at all.

Once again, though, those opinions are split along partisan lines. Almost three-fourths of Democrats said the country has changed for the worse over the past year. Republicans say the country has changed for the better 79 percent to 7 percent.

Independents are nearly evenly split on the question — with 40 percent saying things have gotten worse and 38 percent saying they are better.

It's worth pointing out that those splits come despite the economy's continuing to improve.

A nation divided?

Nearly all Democrats (90 percent) and a majority of independents (59 percent) said they believe the president has divided the nation over the past year.

Trump's numbers with Republicans are a bit softer here, but still, they overwhelmingly (70 percent to 21 percent) said they think he has united the country.

The good: ISIS and the economy

Trump gets his best marks for his handling of ISIS and the state of the economy, but not by overwhelming margins. Almost half (48 percent) approve of how his administration has worked to defeat the terrorist organization, although 40 percent disapprove.

The strong economy is the where Americans see Trump as having the most impact. Twenty-one percent singled out that issue, followed closely by 20 percent who said taxes — just on the heels of the tax overhaul that Congress passed last month.

Forty-four percent of Americans said the economy has improved under Trump, while 35 percent say it has stayed about the same.

On trade, Americans are divided, with 44 percent disapproving of how he has handled the issue and 43 percent approving. Trump pulled the U.S. out of the Trans-Pacific Partnership trade deal after he was elected, and he wanted to renegotiate NAFTA or even end it. That is a winning issue with independents by a 6-point margin, and over three-fourths of Republicans like how he has handled trade.

The bad: everything else

On a host of issues, from race relations to women's rights to foreign policy, Americans think things have gotten worse under this president.

Some 56 percent said race relations have worsened under Trump during the past year. (This survey was conducted before Trump reportedly used vulgar language in a meeting to disparage African nations and wondered why the United States continues to admit people from impoverished countries like Haiti rather than places like — overwhelmingly white — Norway.)

While Republicans support Trump overwhelmingly on almost every other issue including his job performance, his handling of race relations is the one area in which they are split — 24 percent of Republicans believe they have gotten better, 24 percent say they've gotten worse and another 48 percent say they've stayed about the same.

When it comes to women's rights, 37 percent of Americans think things have worsened, 40 percent believe the issue has stayed about the same and 18 percent believe it has improved.

But there is a significant gender gap. Nearly half of women (46 percent) believe the problem has worsened (15 percent think it has gotten better). Men, on the other hand, overwhelmingly think women's rights have stayed about the same (45 percent). One in 5 men (21 percent) think they've gotten better; 29 percent think they've gotten worse.

Trump also gets low marks for how he has handled immigration and health care, with 58 percent disapproving of his handling of both issues.

Republicans failed to repeal the Affordable Care Act, also known as Obamacare. And Congress is trying to find a way forward on how to deal with so-called DREAMers, immigrants who were brought to the United States illegally as children. Some 700,000 had received temporary protection under the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals, or the DACA program set up by President Barack Obama. Trump rescinded the executive order last year, and protections for DACA recipients expire March 5.

Trump has maintained he wants funding for a wall along the southern border with Mexico, which he touted repeatedly on the campaign trail, in exchange for a reprieve from deportation for DACA recipients.

The wall, getting rid of the health care mandate and paying for the tax bill all cost money — and on the deficit, 53 percent of Americans disapprove of how Trump has handled it. Just a third approve.

Major worries about North Korea

On his overall handling of foreign policy, over half (54 percent) of Americans say it has gotten worse over the past year, with a quarter saying it has gotten better.

Trump has gotten into a war of words with North Korean leader Kim Jong Un, threatening military action and even disparagingly tweeting about him, nicknaming Kim "Little Rocket Man."

None of that has helped Trump in the eyes of Americans. Overwhelming numbers say they are concerned about the possibility of war with North Korea.

Seventy-one percent said so, with 44 percent saying they are very concerned.

More than half (58 percent) disapprove of how Trump has handled the rising tensions with the nuclear power, and just over a third approve.

Half of Americans believe North Korea is a major threat to U.S. security — a number that has actually decreased since April, when 61 percent saw it as a major threat. Now, 39 percent classify the country as a minor threat while only 8 percent said it poses no threat at all.

Republicans are the least concerned of any political party subgroup, but a majority (57 percent) still say they are concerned in some way. About a quarter of GOP voters aren't very concerned, with 21 percent saying they aren't concerned at all.

Public remains unconvinced on tax bill

That tax bill is opposed by 46 percent of Americans, with 36 percent saying they approved of the bill. Again, that is split largely along partisan lines, with three-quarters of Republicans favoring the bill, and independents liking it by a 4-point margin. Seventy-nine percent of Democrats opposed the bill.

The problem for Trump and congressional Republicans is that the public overwhelmingly sees the bill as largely helping business over working people nearly 3 to 1 (64 percent to 22 percent). Even Republicans are soft on it, with 47 percent saying it will help working people and 31 percent believing it largely helps businesses.

Still, Americans are nearly evenly split as to whether the bill will hurt their family financially (40 percent) or help them (39 percent.) Sixty-nine percent of Republicans think it will help their family, while 65 percent of Democrats think it will do more harm than good. By a 4-point margin, independent voters think the bill will mostly help them (40 percent) rather than hurt (36 percent).

Overall, Americans think that Trump's policies overwhelmingly support wealthy Americans (60 percent) over the middle class (25 percent) by a 35-point margin. Independents divide along similar lines, while 59 percent of Republicans think his policies help middle-class Americans.

Looking ahead to 2018

Trump's inability to widen his coalition, especially by continuing to alienate independent voters, could be a major detriment in this year's looming midterm elections. Given where his approval ratings are and the fact that the first midterm of a president's term is typically a referendum on his job so far, there area plenty of signs of a possible wave that could flip control of the House — and, in a much longer shot, the Senate.

Congressional Republicans have even lower ratings than Trump, with only 28 percent of Americans approving of the job they're doing, while 61 percent disapprove.

However, the news isn't much better for Democrats, who find themselves in virtually the same position — 28 percent approval with 57 percent disapproval.

When asked who they would vote for in November, Democrats have a 6-point edge over Republicans, 46 percent to 40 percent. That is a shift since Marist last polled in December, finding a 13-point advantage for Democrats. Other recent polling has also given Democrats a double-digit edge — another harbinger of a possible wave that could swing control of the House.

Miringoff attributed the swing — which has also tightened in past polls — to a shift in independent voters moving to uncertain. In this survey, they preferred Republicans by a 2-point margin, 38 percent to 36 percent, with 11 percent undecided. The survey was done when a potential immigration compromise looked possible, as Trump led a bipartisan group of lawmakers in conversation at the White House.

"Democrats and Republicans are mostly locked into supporting their respective party's candidates for Congress. Independents are swayed by what is happening at the time of the survey," Miringoff said. "So, when President Trump is in Asia or his tweeting is less frequent or Congress gets its act together and gets things done, the government looks less dysfunctional. When this happens, the GOP brand is viewed less negatively and the gap between the parties on the congressional generic narrows. "

But when Trump becomes more unpredictable — especially on Twitter — those numbers could shift and harm the GOP. An overwhelming 78 percent majority think that the president's use of Twitter is a risky way to communicate, with just 15 percent saying it sends the right message. Even 57 percent of Republicans think his tweets are often risky, while 31 percent of GOP voters think it sends the right message.

Partisan divide remains strong over past decade

One bit of solace for the Trump White House may be that Obama's numbers on some of those same measures weren't stellar either after his first year. A December 2009 Marist poll found 47 percent said Obama had fallen below their expectations, 42 percent said he had met them and only 7 percent said he had exceeded them.

But he also had a majority on his side when Americans were asked about the direction Obama was taking the country. Trump doesn't have that. Only 44 percent said the country was changing for the better, while 35 percent said it was changing for the worse.

The direction of the country has stayed consistent — on the surface — with Americans appearing to be pessimistic in similar numbers. But inside the numbers, they have shifted in a big way.

In September 2016, 58 percent of Democrats thought the country was moving in the right direction, while 85 percent of Republicans thought it was going in the wrong direction.

Fast-forward to today, and it's the opposite — three-quarters (73 percent) of Republicans think the country is going in the right direction and 84 percent of Democrats think it's the opposite.

Copyright 2018 NPR. To see more, visit


We have a report card this morning for President Trump as we approach the one-year anniversary of his inauguration. It comes from a new NPR/PBS NewsHour/Marist Poll fresh out this morning, and it is not good news for the president. A majority of Americans, 53 percent, say his first year in office has been a failure. NPR's lead political editor Domenico Montanaro is here with more details. Hi, Domenico.


GREENE: So we've heard all year that President Trump's approval ratings have been, you know, at record lows. So I guess this isn't too surprising, but can you dig into why exactly Americans have been unhappy with his performance?

MONTANARO: Yeah. If you look at the issues, I mean, look at foreign policy. Fifty-four percent of Americans say American foreign policy has deteriorated in the last year under this president. Most pressing for a lot of people is North Korea. Fifty-eight percent disapprove of this president's handling of North Korea, and more than 70 percent say they're worried about war breaking out with the country.

GREENE: Wow. That's striking that that people would think a war could be happening soon.

MONTANARO: Absolutely. And it's a huge number, and it's why so many people you can see were so scared when that false alarm went out in Hawaii over the weekend. You know, more than 60 percent say that he's done more to divide the nation than unite it. That's a huge number, 2 to 1. And, not surprising perhaps, given that he's largely played to his base as the president, but, you know, that has helped him keep his base. Among the base, 91 percent say that his year has been a success, but he hasn't played much to the middle.

GREENE: OK. So if he can look at his base as really being behind him, as one positive, are there any other positives in these numbers that the president could look at?

MONTANARO: Yeah, and they shouldn't be overlooked because they're big things - the economy and his handling of ISIS. You know, they're OK numbers for him. You know, by a margin of 48 to 40, people say that they approve of the way he's handled going after the terrorist organization ISIS. And the economy, most people say, is pretty good. So, you know, those are big things, obviously, especially in an election year. But his signature legislative achievement, the tax bill, still unpopular. And he's going to try to sell that today. He's underwater with that. You know, only 36 percent of the country approves of it, and most people, 6 in 10, think that his policies are aimed at helping the rich. Just a quarter say that he's trying to help the middle class.

GREENE: You know, we've been talking about setting up this election year, and there seem to be some competing narratives. I mean, the Republican National Committee seems to have more money than the Democratic Party but the Democrats have won some races that suggest that maybe they could be looking for a good year. Are you learning anything in this poll that might help you predict where these congressional elections might go?

MONTANARO: We always like to have the pollsters test what I call the generic ballot - who do you want to control Congress? And right now Democrats are ahead on that score by six points, but that's not a comfortable lead for Democrats and those hoping that Democrats will take back the House or Senate this fall. You know, I asked our pollster about this, and he said that there largely seems to be a change depending on how Trump comports himself. You know, whether or not he's embroiled in controversy. And we should say that this poll was taken before Trump's disparaging remarks about African countries relating to immigration. And the point was that if he stays cool then it looks like he's plus - you know, that Democrats are plus five or six points as opposed to 17 like we've seen in other polls. That could be worrying for Democrats and also a lesson for President Trump.

GREENE: Domenico, I mean, tell me if I'm wrong, but I think both people who support this president and oppose him would agree that that this first year has been sort of a defining moment in this country. I mean, is there a way to step back and get a sense for where people see this country in, you know, a year into the Trump era?

MONTANARO: So again, this president's got a 37 percent approval rating right now, and 42 percent of the country think the country's changing for the worse. Thirty-six percent think it's changed for the better. So again, we see that mid-30s number for the president on a lot of these scores for his positive marks. Nearly 6 in 10 think the country's going in the wrong direction. And what's fascinating about that is that it's been exactly almost the same number since Barack Obama was in office, but if you look below those numbers, it's been a complete partisan flip. We've seen three-quarters to, you know, 8 in 10 Democrats think that the country's is going in the wrong direction when about that exact same number said they thought it was going pretty well under President Obama.

GREENE: Amazing. OK. A new poll we're seeing this morning as we hit the one-year mark in President Trump's presidency. Speaking about that poll with NPR lead political editor Domenico Montanaro. Domenico, thanks.

MONTANARO: All right. You're welcome. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.